Imagine walking through a busy street wearing a designer suit, only to find someone else wearing an identical outfit and looking exactly like you. It’s a surreal and confusing scenario. This concept mirrors a common issue in the trademark world: "clone" trademarks.
Case Overview
An Italian company, referred to here as ABC COMPANY, owns a series of registered "ABC" trademarks. To its surprise, a "clone" trademark appeared, registered in the United States but bearing the same name and design. This led to confusion and forced ABC COMPANY to seek resolution by applying to the National Intellectual Property Administration, PRC (CNIPA), to update the name associated with its trademarks.
However, CNIPA complicated matters by requiring the company to update the names on 23 other valid trademarks owned by a separate US entity. The confusion stemmed from identical trademarks with only a difference in the registrants' addresses. CNIPA mistakenly assumed that the two entities were the same.
Relevant Legal Framework
Trademark Law Article 41: Requires an application to update any changes to the name, address, or other registered details of a trademark.
Implementing Regulations of Trademark Law Article 30.2: Mandates that changes to a registrant's name or address must apply to all valid trademarks owned by the registrant.
This legal framework informed CNIPA's actions, despite its initial confusion about the ownership of the trademarks.
Resolution and Insights
Through detailed clarification to CNIPA, the Italian company successfully demonstrated its distinction from the US entity and updated its registered information. This case underscores the risks posed by trademark "clones," particularly when registration details are ambiguous or mishandled.
Lessons for Trademark Owners
1. Understand the Risks of Similar Trademarks
In this case, ABC COMPANY registered its trademark in China as early as 1997, covering goods in Class 8. Decades later, a US entity successfully registered a highly similar trademark in the same class in 2021. This scenario conflicts with Trademark Law Article 30, which prohibits identical or similar trademarks for similar goods. The issue likely arose from a procedural error or oversight during the registration process.
2. Regularly Monitor and Protect Your Trademarks
Trademark owners should:
Periodically review their trademark portfolios.
Monitor for newly published trademarks that may conflict with their own.
Act quickly to oppose potentially infringing applications.
Failure to act can lead to "trademark trafficking," where bad-faith registrants exploit these overlaps for profit or competitive harm.
3. Promptly Update Registrant Details
When there is a legitimate change in a trademark owner’s name or address, immediate action is crucial. Delays in updating registration details can create vulnerabilities, as seen in this case.
4. Respond Effectively to Issues
If similar situations arise:
Stay calm and gather relevant documentation.
Communicate clearly with the appropriate trademark authorities.
Submit accurate correction materials to resolve misunderstandings.
Trademark owners should treat clone trademarks as a serious threat to their brand's integrity and value. By maintaining vigilance, acting promptly, and complying with procedural requirements, they can safeguard their rights and minimise risks. When faced with complications like those experienced by ABC COMPANY, strategic and timely action can help navigate these challenges effectively.
Woodburn Accountants & Advisors is one of China’s most trusted business setup advisory firms.
Woodburn Accountants & Advisors is specialized in inbound investment to China and Hong Kong. We focus on eliminating the complexities of corporate services and compliance administration. We help clients with services ranging from trademark registration and company incorporation to the full outsourcing solution for accounting, tax, and human resource services. Our advisory services can be tailor-made based on the companies’ objectives, goals and needs which vary depending on the stage they are at on their journey.
Talk to an expert
Schedule a 30-mins complimentary, no-obligation call to see how Woodburn can help you. Book a call with our Head of Business Advisory - Kristina Koehler-Coluccia.
Topics we can advise on include:
Company Registration
Cloud Accounting & Financial Reporting
Cloud Payroll Services
Tax & Audit Services
Recruitment
Employer-of-Record
Visa Application
Trademark Registration
Switch to Woodburn
Partner with Woodburn (cross referral)
Our calls are automatically scheduled via Zoom - or via Teams, WeChat or WhatsApp upon direct request.
Our advisory calls are available from Monday-Friday from 8am to 5pm CEST and Wednesday until 9pm CEST.