The current global economic slow down has Chinese manufacturers worried about the future of their business. Many international buyers of Chinese manufactured products have been forced to reduce or cancel their orders. However, this situation has motivated a large number of foreign companies to look into doing a joint venture with the Chinese factories.
Disruption creates difficulties, but it also creates opportunities. Post-COVID-19, investors have an opportunity to benefit from first mover advantage in this new world: one of the ways to do this will be through International Joint Ventures (IJVs).
The majority of IJVs in China are manufacturing companies. This is viewed by the Chinese authorities as the preferable form of foreign investment because they provide an opportunity for the transfer of advanced technology and management skills to the Chinese economy and lead to increased exports.
Foreign companies have a particular interest in manufacturing in China, as it gives them access to the large Chinese market and to potentially low production costs.
The international economic slow down has also created a high degree of market uncertainty. When uncertainty is high, joint ventures become more attractive. They require less initial investment than the alternatives and can be set up with a clear exit mechanism in mind.
According to a study done by Deloitte, the COVID-19 pandemic is creating conditions that increasingly favor JVs. IJVs also offer an advantage in accessing markets with heavy regulatory restrictions. This is the case in China which effectively limits foreign investment in certain industries if the foreign investor does not partner with a local firm.
However, there is a notable trend towards opening more industries to foreign investment, with the Chinese government recently reducing foreign ownership restrictions on investments in finance and the automobile industry.
The rising risks and costs of products due to supply chain disruptions, inflation and tariffs are also pushing companies to consider a JV, which would allow both sides to share the increasing burden.
Another way for both the foreign buyer and its Chinese manufacturer to reduce risks and increase sales and profits is to have the manufacturer sell the foreign buyer’s products in China.
Many experts consider though that JVs in China tend to favor the local partner and rarely make sense for the foreign company. Joint ventures with Chinese suppliers have their own special issues/problems and they expose the foreign side to risks such as IP theft, and battles of control over the business.
Chinese factories usually know little about how to market products (even their own) in China or anywhere else and when they are your factory and your joint venture partner, it can be difficult for you to monitor the joint venture’s sales and profits.
It usually does not make sense for a foreign company to become a co-owner of a joint venture entity with its Chinese manufacturer before it knows how good that factory will be at selling the foreign company’s product in China.
A China-centric distribution agreement could be a better option to set forth sales goals. It also allows the foreign company to walk away if the Chinese factory does not meet those goals. Having a trademark licensing agreement with the distributor also makes sense.
IJV manufacturers in China face many challenges, such as difficulty with recruiting and training suitable employees; all aspects of supplier management; problems with achieving high-quality output; and achieving an effective IJV business culture.
Investments in IJV manufacturing are often thought worthwhile because of the strategic benefits they can bring to both local and foreign partners. But despite their apparent advantages, IJVs in China are not always successful and parent companies are often dissatisfied with IJV performance. In addition, it has been identified that poor financial performance is often related to operational problems.
IJVs are a means for a business to get its foot in the door and establish itself in a new market. Consequently, measuring the success of an IJV should consider what the stated objectives of the venture were at the time of signing and ask whether the IJV achieved the desired objectives.
Over 90% of ventures in China under the age of 15 are still operating today. Remarkably, nearly 70% of ventures over 25 years old are still legally operating. It is worth noting, though, that some of this high survival rate could be partially attributable to the legal difficulty of winding down a company in the country.
IJVs make up a substantial proportion of foreign investment in China. Since 2010 roughly 40% of foreign funded capital into China has come via Joint Ventures. IJVs also allow the foreign partner to make use of the local knowhow, access to capital, business relationships and talent of its local Chinese counterpart.
According to Deloitte, Chinese-based IJVs will continue to be attractive to western companies after COVID-19. American and European firms will seek to leverage the relatively high growth rates possible in the Chinese market. Firms investing in China can take advantage of the increasingly skilled and sizable workforce and comprehensive supply chains.
Western companies seeking to undertake joint ventures in China need to consider the idiosyncrasies of the Chinese market and take the time to understand the market and business culture.
It is crucial for both sides to clearly understand the strategic goals of both parties. A JV can only succeed where interests coincide.
Much of the success of an IJV in China hinges on finding the right partner from the beginning. Firms need to take the time to assess if their potential partner has an alignment of goals, has the necessary business capability, and is trustworthy.
To learn more about our services in China, contact our Head of Business Advisory - Ms. Kristina Koehler-Coluccia at kristina@woodburnglobal.com.
DISCLAIMER: All information in this article is verified to the best of our ability and is assumed to be correct at time of release; however, Woodburn Accountants & Advisors does not accept responsibility for any losses arising from reliance on the information provided within. The information provided is for general guidance and does not replace specialized advice.